Editor’s Choice: HP Z1 Workstation Review and Real World Test Drive John P. October 10, 2013 Editor's Choice, Reviews 10 Comments 700 Shares Google+ 311 Twitter 72 Facebook 276 LinkedIn 40 Reddit 0 Pin It Share 0 Buffer 1 700 Shares × If God needed a computer, this is the one he would build. In fact, you don’t need to even read the rest of this review – if you’re looking for a computer for your home, or 100 for your office, the HP Z1 Workstation is the right computer. Period. Oh, so you want to hear more? “Amuse me Mr. Geek Man,” you say? Well fine. I can go all day talking about the Z1, so go get some popcorn or something. Because this is gonna be a long one. Unboxing the HP Z1 Workstation When the Z1 Workstation arrived, it came in one of the biggest boxes ever! The packaging was actually impressive! Here’s what happened when we unboxed it. HP Z1 Workstation Details The first thing to keep in mind is that the HP Z1 doesn’t come in just one flavor. You need to broaden your thinking and consider the Z1 as more of a platform that you can build upon. The Z1 can be optioned lean enough to come in at a starting price around $1,800 – perfect for light home use or maybe something for the secretarial pool (do those even exist any more?), all the way up to a bank-breaking $8,700+ for your hard-core multimedia intensive users like architects, artists, and multimedia professionals. HP Z1 Workstations Include A fantastic 27″ 2560 x 1440 LED IPS display DVD or Blu-ray writer Up to 32GB of RAM Either ONE 7200 RPM or 10k RPM 3.5″ drive, or up to TWO SSDs 4 Video choices from a base integrated video card up to the NVIDIA Quadro K4000M Ports galore – 2 x USB 3.0, 4 x USB 2.0, mic/headphone/Optical out/Subwoofer out + a Card reader Up to a 5-year warranty from HP An integrated 1080p 2.0MP webcam, which is rotatable to disable Yeah, that last little point is worth calling out. HP has an elegantly simple method of closing off the camera! Just swivel it. Why doesn’t EVERY camera do this? HP Z1 Acoustics One area that really deserves some special attention is the acoustics associated with the Z1. In fact, there basically aren’t any! You know how most machines sit on your desk and you hear the fans spinning away. LOUDLY. Well, the Z1 uses no fewer than nine thermal sensors to control six separate fans which only cool the various parts when necessary. The internals on the Z1 are broken up into four distinct cooling zones: The Processor Graphics Optical / Memory / Display Controls Drives Each area can essentially cool itself as needed. In addition, HP uses larger than normal cooling fans, which allow them to spin slower while still moving the same amount of air. See what I mean when I say the engineers spent a lot of time on this one! A Few Nitpicks We’re always the most critical of those we love. And I do love thee Z1! So why can’t you be perfect? Here’s what I don’t like. A truly rotten keyboard. The massive keys, combined with the excessive travel and a clicking noise that would drive anyone mad. No Thunderbolt ports. I don’t care that they are only found on Macs! Get some! The four USB 2.0 ports on the back. Why can’t they all be 3.0? The base is a little weak, sometimes letting the monitor sag from a higher position. A DisplayPort for external monitors? I don’t even know where to find an adapter for that. How about HDMI instead? HP Z1 Professional Construction Everything about the Z1 is built to last. From the sturdy chassis all the way down to the individual components. But what’s even better than being built to last, is being built to be serviced! The HP engineers who designed the Z1 put a lot of thought into how each of the pieces would lay out within the chassis in order to ensure that not only did everything fit, but it had plenty of room for adequate ventilation as well as ease of replacement. Throughout the internals it’s incredibly easy to spot the green tabs which allow each and every component to be swapped out. Need to put in a new video card? 5 seconds and you’re done. Hard drive? DVD Burner? RAM? Check. Everything you might need to replace can be done so in seconds. Check it out, I swapped out a DVD drive and it was so easy I actually thought it should have been harder! The ease of repair must be taken into account when you consider the life span of these machines and the fact that most will make their way into enterprise environments. It would dramatically speed up the mean time to repair for IT environments who could simply roll a cart to a user’s desk, pop open the lid and change a part in seconds, as opposed to needing to take a computer back to the lab where the chassis would need to be disassembled and the internals would have to become externals just to get to the part you need to replace. HP Z1 Workstation Options If you’re going to choose how to option up the Z1 it helps to understand which things make for the biggest price jumps. HP Z1 Processors The Z1 comes with a pretty good choice of processors ranging from the Intel i3 line, up to the quad core Xeons. But what are the real differences? Well… Xeon processors – have more cache, run cooler and at lower voltages, and are designed for 24/7 continuous usage. They can also be used in multi-socket motherboards so this is the same processor type you’ll find in Apple’s Mac Pros. The processors, and the motherboards that support them, cost a lot more than the consumer-oriented i3 – i7 line of Intel processors. Having said that, if the workstation is not destined for heavy computational use (like graphic design, massive number crunching, etc.) one of the i3 or i5 processors would work just fine for things like email, word processing and web surfing. And there’s a $1,000 price difference between the entry level i3 and the high end Xeon processor, so that’ll save some major coinage. HP Z1 Video Cards At the bottom end of the range, the HP Z1 Workstation basically includes a video card that is integrated directly into the CPU. The video is certainly capable of driving the 27″ high resolution screen, as well as powering an external monitor, and it will play movies and games, etc. Having said that, if you upgrade to the NVIDIA Quadro K4000M it will provide 800% faster performance in terms of smoothing out motion video and drawing complex things on screen. People working in applications like AutoCAD, or doing heavy multimedia editing will dramatically benefit from the much faster video processing, though the $1,400 price differential makes this about the most expensive upgrade you can make to the machine. For full disclosure, if you were to purchase a Quadro 4000 video card for any other computer it would be closer to an $800 card. So there is definitely a premium to fit it into this chassis. But again, keep in mind that HP is warrantying this part for years, and servicing it is much easier. HP Z1 Drive Choices The hard drive you select is probably the single most important factor in terms of making the machine “feel” snappy. Most laptops or consumer grade computers come with drives that spin at 5,400 rpms or slower. That works well for conserving power, but it makes for a very s-l-o-w experience. The Z1 however starts with 7,200 rpm drives as its base option (normally the high end on other machines), and moves up from there. You’ll notice that the machine I tested came with the 10,000 rpm drive, which is very fast indeed (for a hard drive). These drives, like the Xeon processors, are reserved for machines that are destined to see duty 24/7. They are fast, reliable, and expensive, adding over $250 to the base price. But in this machine I wouldn’t want anything less. In fact, if you want maximum performance, the optimal configuration for the HP Z1 would be to upgrade to a pair of 500GB SSD drives configured in a RAID 1 striped array. This would allow the machine to take full advantage of its dual 6GB SATA controllers and really, really scream. Doing so would add nearly $2,000 to the price of the Z1, which is more than double what it would cost to slap a pair of SSDs in a traditional computer if you did it yourself. But again, the extra $grand or so you spend saves you down the road if you ever need any repair. HP Z1 Memory Choices When it comes to things like the video card, and probably the hard drives, I think it makes sense to go with the more expensive OEM installed options. You just don’t want the problems associated with plugging in things that aren’t certified and warranted to go with that machine. But when it comes to RAM? Skip it. In order to upgrade the RAM all the way to the chassis maxing 32GB it would cost $1,700+, but you can head right on over to Crucial and purchase 32GB for this machine for just over $400. And since the Z1 is so simple to service, all you literally need to do is open the screen and plug in the RAM. You’re done! HP Z1 Final Comments Having said all that, I’m not sure what else you might want to know, so ask questions below and I’ll answer them in the comments. But in the meantime, we’re handing the HP Z1 Workstation a Geek Beat Editor’s Choice award. Heck, this machine is so awesome that I’d give it a Nobel Prize if I could… but HP will just have to settle for our Editor’s Choice. HP Z1 Photos 10 Responses Kris_M November 6, 2013 Mister John P. – Looking at your presentations of Z1 I really do agree that this is the best built computer in the world. Like IBM PS2 there are no visible wires and harnesses, all modules seem to fit each other. Modularization allows to customize and reconfigure great deal. I would buy it at once. The only issue I have is the display – it looks like chip tv set from Wallmart. Looking at the presentations I got an impression though that the display is as glossy as practically all Apple screens. I have made my mistake once, I purchased HP laptop without checking the quality of the display. Yes, it is a good computer but I can use it only at night. Otherwise the display produces so many reflections that it is like a philharmonic concert in open tent on Middle East fish market. Barely readable, sometimes not at all. So everyday I use high quality glare free laptop Latitude E6530 with external glare free Dell display and at home high quality glare free Acer AL2216W display. Sir, what’s your opinion on that? Eberhard October 29, 2013 I would buy the Z1 today, if it had a touch display and Windows 8.1. I hope, a Z2 will come soon. Zig Baird October 24, 2013 As a longtime PC guy who converted to Mac and vowed to never buy another PC, this review actually gave me pause. I love the ingenuity that went into the Z1 case. It seems like one could buy the base model and then add better components as they see fit if they don’t want to upgrade at the time of purchase. The accessibility is what amazes me most. Sean October 21, 2013 Ziad, please remove your comment, i find it offensive that you would assume to speak for God. The Afghanistan I.T industry may need to use any of the 8 billion other websites out there while you plan your strongly worded ignorance. Everyone knows the Mormon God is the one true God and you need to remove your comment before we consider reading someone elses confession of Muslim heresy. Seems rude and ignorant, doesn’t it? Ziad Ras October 20, 2013 Hi John, It’s nice review and this workstation seem to be really impressive, and I would strongly recommend it. But I want to notify you again about the wording used in the review, you have started the review by “If God needed a computer, this is the one he would build” This sentence should not been used its very offensive to many religions like Islam and its insulting to believers. Because GOD is not to be compared by human and will not need to use such !!! Please remove this part or change it something else. Otherwise we are going to raise a case against you and Geekbeat and to ask people not to visit the website and your portal and not to consider your reviews by any chance in the future. Thanks for understanding Marty October 11, 2013 Working in IT, I used to have the same take on DisplayPort as you, but then I actually researched it and realized WHY it is standard on small form factor PCs like all-in-ones and laptops; It can carry many more formats than simply HDMI or any other single channel. From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Displayport: DisplayPort is a digital display interface developed by the Video Electronics Standards Association (VESA). The interface is primarily used to connect a video source to a display device such as a computer monitor, though it can also be used to transmit audio, USB, and other forms of data. The VESA specification is royalty-free. VESA designed it to replace VGA, DVI, and FPD-Link. Backward compatibility to VGA and DVI by using active adapter dongles enables users to use DisplayPort fitted video sources without replacing existing display devices. John P. October 11, 2013 Thanks for the explanation Marty. Makes sense, though personally I’d rather give up a little functionality for the ease of use of grabbing an HDMI cable and just plugging it into any old monitor laying around. Cheers, John P. JoeCool October 11, 2013 Another great review JP, I used to work for Compaq before they purchased DEC, I was the Professional Workstation Trainer for North America Training Group. This system reminds me of the 5000 model line when they first came out. Although the best workstation I’ve ever seen was the Alpha AXP, if ever there was a workstation I’d like to see HP bring back it would be the Alpha and the Laptop DEC made. That system would run circles around Compaqs complete line of workstations. Vernon White October 10, 2013 Here are a few HP Display Port to HDMI solutions… We use a lot of them at my work since we are mostly an HP shop… Small dongle from Monoprice… http://www.monoprice.com/products/product.asp?c_id=104&cp_id=10428&cs_id=1042801&p_id=4826&seq=1&format=2 Extron Electronics makes a great adapter… http://www.extron.com/product/product.aspx?id=dpmadt&search=dpm-hdmif and a dongle… http://www.extron.com/product/product.aspx?id=dphdmif&s=5 and a cable… http://www.extron.com/product/product.aspx?id=dpseries&search=DisplayPort%20to%20HDMI So you can go from DisplayPort to HDMI neatly… Great review. I’m going to have to show this model to my supervisor as we are building mobile switching and webcast rigs for use in our company. That might solve two issues in one… Thanks for doing all the stuff you, Cali, Dave C, and the rest of your crew does on Geek Beat! Vernon John P. October 10, 2013 Thanks for the tips Vernon! Glad the review might be of a little assistance. And thanks for watching!